25.1.07

Do We Hate Kids?!?

Just a quick question... can someone explain when it became anything less than disturbing to produce movies intended for mass market distribution that include rape scenes of minors? Free speech experts might claim that this is a film, that it is acting and that it is artistic expression... i guess my concern is where have we gone off the path?

i can appreciate trying to tell a good story but what about telling a good story and doing so with good taste? Am i wrong here? Am i missing something? The 12 year old child actress that appears in this film and in particular the rape scene, was actually trotted out in front of an inquiring public and defended not only the specific scene but explained to everyone that what she was actually doing "is called acting"... Huh? Sorry, that's just weird, creepy, disturbing and everything other adjective that would relate to the previous three!

Over the last several days i have heard several reasons why this is really not all that big of a deal. Some would say say in response to other's objections toward this type of material that it is important that adults not shield children from the difficulties of life. On the surface that sounds reasonable but what sane parent would give their child alcoholic beverages with the intent of NOT shielding them from the effects of alcohol? i see this deal with this film and with allowing this 12 year old actress to perform this type of disturbing scene in the same light... it is parenting gone strikingly awry!

i am alright with making the mistake "over protecting" my daughter. Growing up i needed someone to protect me from many of the things that i encountered at way too early an age and was not ready to deal with on an emotional or physical level. If i can protect not just my daughter but my sons also no matter what the cost, i'll do it, no question about it. Even if that means being called "over protective"... i have been called much worse.

Like i said to start with, this is the type of reasonable discussion we should be having about this type of issue in our nation but typically it degenerates into a labeling, name-calling, hostile, yelling match and the discussion never occurs. How sad is that?

What is the answer to this type of situation in our culture? i think part of the deal is that we need to stop using children as props. We need to treasure children for being children and stop seeing them as an impediments, status symbols or trophies. i find myself growing more than a bit weary of seeing children on the laps and in the arms of public figures who seem to be playing the "lets-do-it-(whatever it is) for-the-kids" card.

i love the fact that i have at least three children who are in no particular hurry to grow up! They love to pretend, play with Lego® blocks, have made up stories told to them, play board games & play hide and seek. They just like being children and that is awesome! Seems like we (adults) have come to believe that childhood is the real inconvenient truth.

A film which includes a graphically suggested scene of a 12 year old girl being sexually violated indicates an ominous trend in our culture... children and childhood are really nothing special. How sad is that?

1 comment:

Anonymous said...

You entitle your blog entry " Do We Hate Children?." You describe any appetite to consume media containing this type of scene as "weird, creepy, disturbing." You then assert any reasonable discussion "degenerates into a labeling, name-calling, hostile, yelling match."

It seems to me that by using the words above, you are bordering on being guilty of doing that which you fault in others.

I think fair-minded, well-intentioned and reasonable people can disagree about whether the scene is appropriate. Regardless of anyone's specifc belief, I think an overwhelming majority would support your right to protect your children from these type of movies and/or subject matter until you see fit.

Millions of people across our country will see this movie and perhaps deveolp a greater appreciation of the violence that is inflicted on children and women throughout the world. The fact that this violence is morally reprehensible does not mean that the story of its occurrence should not be told. Many historical and social facts are unappealing (e.g., slavery, Holocaust, Crusades, etc.) but nevertheless should be learned about and otherwise represented without sugarcoating.

I haven't seen a horror movie in years - I really can't stand to see blood and guts. [Seriously, I close my eyes during the television broadcast of ER on NBC during the more gruesome parts.] I just can't stomach that stuff - truth be told I don't see how anybody can watch those type of movies. That said, when the Passion of Christ was released - among a multitude of other things -I heard alot about the graphic and gruesome scenes depicted during the crucifixion. In my opinion - I think the graphic depiction is probably the most accurate way to tell the story. The idea is that it was not a pretty death and should not be portrayed as one. I think the same can be said of the events surrounding a twelve-year old rape victim.

Labels

I AM NOT HAPPY AT ALL!

I AM NOT HAPPY AT ALL!
Welcome to our world little dude!